Raise the quality of government spending

By Vinod Thomas
0 CommentsPrint E-mail China Daily, November 25, 2009
Adjust font size:

The incipient recovery of the world economy owes to the increased spending by governments of advanced and developing economies both. However, a sustainable recovery will depend not only on the amount of spending, but also on its quality. Many developing nations entered the crisis with good fiscal balances. Yet, there is a premium everywhere on ensuring that the money is spent well. Public budgets must also confront the rise in unemployment and the growing danger of climate change.

These requirements suggest three priorities, especially for countries at the forefront of the fiscal expansion.

First, financial flows need to be adequate and timely, especially in the face of growing fiscal gaps. The international financial institutions have augmented their official flows, especially to developing countries. The World Bank Group delivered a record $60 billion worldwide in 2009, with Indonesia, Brazil, Mexico, India, and China as the top recipients. The IMF's support reached $160 billion globally while the Asian, African, European, and inter-American development banks provided unprecedented volumes to their regions.

All this has helped, but to sustain the economic revival, private capital flows must also be re-invigorated. Private financial flows to developing countries fell from $1,200 billion in 2007 to $360 billion in 2009. Reversing this trend is fundamental. The poorer developing countries still face a $12-billion gap this year, and may not be able to cover even the most essential social spending. And across the board, the extraordinary fiscal expansion needs to give way to a pickup in private consumption and investment.

Second, it is essential to manage the growing government deficits from the fiscal stimulus and the economic slowdown. Fiscal deficits in 2009 are estimated to be nearly 7 percentage points of GDP higher than in 2007 in G20 nations, and 5 percentage points higher in G20 emerging economies. The ratio of public debt-to-GDP in the G20 could, by one estimate, rise by nearly 15 percentage points between these years. Going forward, a sharp fiscal adjustment and stronger growth will be needed to pay off the debt.

To generate economic growth, the stimulus spending needs to be directed to high-productivity areas. For example, channeling outlays to finish infrastructure projects has higher payoffs than providing untargeted subsidies, be it for energy or food. But even here, any spending on infrastructure would not automatically generate growth. And only a few countries have put in place mechanisms for analyzing, tracking, and evaluating project costs and benefits.

Third, with nearly 90 million more people pushed into poverty because of the crisis, effective social programs (in education, health, and safety nets) need to be protected. Some countries are shielding social spending and expanding safety nets. In Brazil, Colombia, Mexico, and Turkey, where strong institutions are in place, conditional cash transfers are effective. China has combined labor market actions and safety nets to stabilize employment, while Indonesia has combined safety nets and livelihood approaches. The World Bank has stepped up lending for social programs, especially financing for safety nets.

Unfortunately the financial crisis has diluted attention to climate change and the environment. Yet, the fiscal stimulus presents an opportunity to shift to sustainable investments - as South Korea, China, Mexico and the US are doing to some degree. The World Bank Group has increased support for renewable energy and spearheaded climate funds. The Copenhagen summit in December provides a chance to integrate climate change into the crisis response.

Since the global economic revival is still fragile, it would be premature to retract the fiscal expansion as that could stall the recovery.

However, rising deficits and debts oblige us to ensure that the money is put to effective use - not only to elicit good returns on the public spending, but also to avoid a future crisis.

The author is director-general of the Independent Evaluation Group, the World Bank, Washington D.C.

PrintE-mail Bookmark and Share

Comments

No comments.

Add your comments...

  • User Name Required
  • Your Comment
  • Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
Send your storiesGet more from China.org.cnMobileRSSNewsletter
主站蜘蛛池模板: 影音先锋在线_让看片永远陪伴| 欧美人与性动交另类| 国产乱子伦农村XXXX| 欧美疯狂ⅹbbbb另类| 国产香蕉97碰碰久久人人| www日本在线观看| 成人黄软件网18免费下载成人黄18免费视频 | 免费黄网在线观看| 老子影院dy888午夜| 日本边添边摸边做边爱喷水| 免费激情视频网站| 老司机天堂影院| 国产乱子伦农村xxxx| 黑人性受xxxx黑人xyx性爽| 太粗太深了用力点视频| 东北老妇露脸xxxxx| 无码中文字幕日韩专区| 久久久久无码国产精品一区| 日韩在线小视频| 乱人伦视频中文字幕| 欧美中文在线视频| 亚洲国产情侣一区二区三区| 欧美粗大猛烈老熟妇| 亚洲第一极品精品无码久久| 狠狠色综合网站久久久久久久| 免费观看欧美一级牲片一| 精品国产中文字幕| 午夜精品视频5000| 美女无遮挡免费视频网站| 国产特级毛片AAAAAA| 探花视频在线看视频| 国产精品无码素人福利不卡| 91久久大香线蕉| 好男人资源在线观看好| 一级毛片短视频| 强挺进小y头的小花苞漫画| 中文字幕丰满乱子伦无码专区 | 欧美人与性囗牲恔配| 亚洲人精品亚洲人成在线| 欧美国产一区二区三区激情无套| 亚洲国产美女精品久久久久|